PDA

View Full Version : DCL may move to another port


Robin
07-24-2007, 09:28 PM
This is a rumor since no decision has been made yet.

When I've cruised to the Caribbean I've sailed out of both Miami and San Juan, Puerto Rico. The San Juan port gives ships the ability to travel further south on a 7 day cruise.

Disney could want the option of a new itinerary or simply let Port Canaveral know it's saying is not guaranteed, hope they sweeten any deal they are working on.


Disney ships may drift away from Brevard port

The Disney Magic has been based at Port Canaveral for nearly a decade. As Disney Cruise Line plans to double its fleet by 2012, the company may move some of its operations away from the Brevard port.

Jason Garcia
Orlando Sentinel
July 24, 2007

"We are having some discussions about the longer term," said Stan Payne, Port Canaveral's chief executive officer.

Disney officials say they have been pleased with their tenure at the Brevard County port, which sits just 60 miles from Walt Disney World and where the company waded into the industry by packaging three- and four-night Caribbean cruises with stays at its mega-resort.

But with fuel prices surging and the company planning to double the size of its fleet to four ships by 2012, they say Canaveral is no longer the only port that makes sense for their growing cruise line.

Tom Wolber, Disney Cruise Line's senior vice president of operations, said competing ports in Miami and Fort Lauderdale "are obviously other alternatives to be considered."

"As we are in negotiations, we look at all the potential opportunities that are out there. And our business model has changed over time," Wolber said. "There are pros and cons to each one."

Disney's flexibility

Disney's original deal with Port Canaveral included a number of perks.

Agreed to in May 1995, the terms required Port Canaveral to build a $26.2 million terminal to Disney's exact specifications -- Disney representatives had the right to inspect and order changes to blueprints at multiple points throughout the design stage.

Disney paid about $7.5 million last year to the port in dockage, parking and other fees. Port officials also say Disney and other big cruise lines bring millions in related spending, creating everything from concession sales to jobs.

What's more, the contract also gives Disney exclusive access to the terminal provided its ships make at least 150 calls a year, an obligation it has so far met. That prevents rival cruise ships that call on Canaveral from using Disney's terminal. It's the only time Port Canaveral has made such made an arrangement with a multiday cruise line.

Disney is likely to seek similar concessions as it discusses new terms with the port.

Payne said preliminary talks have focused on what improvements Canaveral must make to accommodate the company's two new ships -- 122,000-ton liners that will each be two decks taller and about 45 percent larger than the Magic and the Wonder.

The work will almost certainly entail millions of dollars' worth of upgrades around Disney's terminal, Payne said, from widening gangways to expanding parking lots.

"It's just a matter of planning both shoreside for a larger ship and landside for more passengers," Payne said.

Payne also expects Disney to seek a lower number of minimum visits its ships must make in order to maintain its exclusive terminal access and give the company more flexibility.

Disney appears in no rush to announce its plans. Its current deal with Port Canaveral includes options -- at Disney's sole discretion -- to extend by one year for each of the next 40 years. And the company has tacitly signaled its plans to extend at least once by accepting bookings for cruises out of Canaveral throughout 2008.

Maintaining ties

Analysts say there is almost no chance Disney would move completely out of Port Canaveral. It is, after all, the closest port to Walt Disney World.

But they do say there is a possibility the company could choose to move at least one of the ships and that it is unlikely, when the two new vessels arrive in 2011 and 2012, that they would position three at Port Canaveral.

Sailing out of Brevard County has its drawbacks. At about 200 miles north of Fort Lauderdale's Port Everglades and even farther from the Port of Miami, Port Canaveral is much farther from the Caribbean, where Disney owns an island dubbed Castaway Cay.
With fuel prices what they are, it's a significant cost to sail that extra couple hundred miles on every cruise," said Robert LaFleur, a tourism-industry analyst with the Susquehanna Financial Group. "You're probably talking thousands and thousands of dollars on every cruise."

Others say that as Disney has become more established in the cruise industry, it is catering more to sophisticated cruisers and less to customers who want to couple short cruise trips with visits to Disney World.

Indeed, Disney Cruise Line has already experimented with itineraries on the West Coast -- near Disneyland in Anaheim, Calif. -- and in Europe. The Magic is spending this summer sailing 10- and 11-day Mediterranean cruises out of Barcelona, Spain.

"The Disney brand and franchise is clearly international in scope, and, as they have become more experienced in their operating of a cruise line and a fleet, this would translate very nicely to Europe and, at a point down the road, Asia," said David Leibowitz, an analyst with Burnham Securities.

Top officials at both the Port of Miami and Port Everglades say they have not seriously discussed hosting a ship with Disney.

Marilyn Green, the former cruise editor at Travel Trade magazine, said many industry watchers expect Disney to initially station its new, larger ships at Port Canaveral -- at least until a widening of the Panama Canal is completed -- while the two older ships are deployed to the West Coast and Europe.

Rena Langley, a spokeswoman for Disney Cruise Line, said Port Canaveral will remain an important base for the company.

"We think it's one of the best terminals in the world," she said, though she added, "We're always in discussions with Port Canaveral on how to raise the bar."

MichellesCharmWorld
01-03-2008, 10:52 AM
oh wow!! I hadn't heard of this. I'm glad they plan on at least keeping some ships in Canaveral! I love the proximity to WDW!

Photographer
01-03-2008, 12:19 PM
I've always wanted to sail from Miami. I'd also gladly take a cruise to/from San Juan, Puerto Rico. En San Juan me enamore bajo la luna...

krdisneybound
01-03-2008, 01:33 PM
this has been in the works for a while. I seem to think that Pt. Canaveral will stay.

If I remember correctly, I was in a discussion with someone just recently and DCL was fined many, many thousands of dollars for not making their docking quotas for 2007. That was due to the Magic being in the Med.

Tampa was/is being looked at also.

There is no room for two DCL ships, right now, to be at Pt. Canaveral. The Magic was over by the silos when they were both recently in dock. That was only temporary, until the Wonder left.

There are lots of rumors floating around right now.

WillCAD
01-04-2008, 12:00 AM
Yeah, that wonderful facility they built for the DCL ships can only handle one ship at a time. With only two ships in the fleet, that wasn't a problem, but with 4 ships, it might become a problem with scheduling.

However, my bet is that Disney will continue to operate two ships out of Port Canaveral for Bahamian and Carribean cruises, while the other two will be split between west coast and other cruises.

DCL has experimented with the Med and west coast itineraries and all the cruises sold out quickly; I bet that Disney will want to operate Mexico cruises from L.A., and will probably experiment with Alaskan ittineraries and maybe Polynesian or western Pacific itineraries once they get a port facility somewhere on the west coast.

And I think they'll probably experiment with more Atlantic and Med itineraries, too. Who knows - they may have some sort of master plan to eventually expand the fleet some more once they figure out what the most popular and profitable itineraries might be.

Both Tokyo and Hong Kong have Disney parks AND big, busy harbors... DLP is only about 90 miles from the coast (not as convenient as WDW but feasible)... adding cruises near the other Disney parks isn't a huge stretch of the imagination.

Robin
01-04-2008, 12:34 AM
The Caribbean is traditionally less popular in the summer, which makes it a good time for Disney to move ships around to the West Coast or Europe. It also gets some of the fleet out of the area in case of a more active hurricane season.

Another reason for a second port, at least further south (Miami or Puerto Rico) is to cut a day off travel time if they want to reach islands further south. When I went on my first cruise years ago, even with leaving from San Juan, it took a full day at sea to reach Barbados.

I think we'll see at at least one more home port for DCL once the new ships are ready. With the new ships being larger, I wonder if Port Canaveral will be able to accommodate them.

Then again, the point of this 'rumor' could be to remind Port Canaveral they aren't guaranteed the next two ships.

Robin
01-04-2008, 12:39 AM
From the Orlando Sentinel's Central Florida Tourism blog:

Disney Cruise Line to Add Ports of Call

posted by Chris Boyd on Dec 5, 2007 11:10:24 AM
Disney Cruise Line plans to make Port Canaveral home base for both its ships in 2009, ending a four-year adventure that sent one of them to distant waters in the Pacific and Mediterranean.


The company will return the Magic to Central Florida, where it will spend the year cruising the Caribbean. Its new schedule will include four seven-night itineraries -- three that visit islands in the eastern part of the sea and one that goes west.


"It's all about listening to our guests," said Disney Cruise Line President Tom McAlpin, who added the decision to return the cruise ship Magic to Port Canaveral is a response to customer interest.


The new schedule adds new options to next summer's lineup as well, including trips to the Mexican Riviera and some cruises that make multiple stops at Castaway Cay, Disney's private island in the Bahamas.


McAlpin said the decision to make Port Canaveral home port to both its ships in 2009 is unrelated to a problem it faced this year when the port charged the company $107,000 for not meeting a usage quota.


Disney's contract requires that the company make at least 150 calls to Canaveral each year to maintain exclusive use of its Port Canaveral cruise terminal. During the year ended in July, its shipped moored there 139 times -- the result of the Magic's deployment to the Mediterranean.


"The $107,000 is a nominal amount," McAlpin said. "This decision has nothing to do with that. We wouldn't make this type of decision based on that kind of fee."


McAlpin said the company isn't ready to make announcements about its 2010 deployments, but he said it will be a pivotal year as Disney prepares to receive two new, and larger, ships.


The first of the two ships, which haven't been named, will be delivered in 2011, the second in 2012.


Disney's 10-year contract with Port Canaveral expires in 2008 but is renewable annually for 40 years. McAlpin would not talk about the company's discussions with the port.


"The nature of our business is that we have assets that are mobile," he said. "We have a great relationship with Port Canaveral and our goal is to continue to do business with them."



This confirms my belief that there won't be any real changes until the new ships arrive, and how they will be deployed isn't etched in stone.

MissBianca
01-04-2008, 02:45 AM
The Caribbean cruise that we took years ago used Puerto Rico as its home port. It was like having another destination on the cruise and we enjoyed seeing San Juan, but it wasn't easy to get flights in and out of there. Pricey too. Tradeoffs, tradeoffs.

kathleena
01-05-2008, 02:25 PM
As said in the article, $107k to them is just spit. There wouldn't have been a decision made to go to Europe without evaluating exactly how much it would cost them. So they decided they would make up the fees in bookings.

I agree with the thought they will send the Wonder and Magic to other areas of the world and keep the two new ships (let say.......Dreams and Imagine......) in FL. Then they could just stay at PC anyway.......

Robin
01-05-2008, 04:22 PM
I wouldn't be surprised to learn that $107k was factored into the cost of the Mediterranean cruise.

I looked up the latest on the ships over at the builder's site, and it looks like they are still in the planning stage. I doubt they'll make any decisions on their homeport, until actually construction starts.

http://www.meyerwerft.de/page.asp?lang=e&main=3&subs=0&did=1463

It will be cool in a few years ago actually see the ships taking shape.

The webcam shows two other ships currently under construction:
http://www.meyerwerft.de/page.asp?lang=e&main=2&subs=0&did=826

Timon
01-05-2008, 05:36 PM
My hope is that they stick with Port Canaveral or if they must move they go west out of Tampa. San Juan is out of the question for me and while Ft. Lauderdale and Miami aren't out of the question there's no way we'd combine a WDW trip with a DCL trip as we do now. The synergy of combining a DCL & WDW trip works with Port Canaveral and Tampa, but not nearly as well with Ft. Lauderdale or Miami and not at all with San Juan.

sjh801
01-06-2008, 03:15 PM
:confused:
Hey! We have three rivers here in Pittsburgh! Maybe they will want to sail out of here!!!;)

Robin
01-06-2008, 03:43 PM
I'm thinking only one or two ships 'might' get a different homeport.

It seems reasonable that the furtherst port a (regularly scheduled) cruise would visit would be one day away. If they move one ship down to Miami, they can offer 7 day cruises that travel that much further south in the Caribbean.

I don't think they will drop Port Canaveral as much as keeping their options open so they can add more variety. And it doesn't hurt when going into re-negotiations to let the other side think there is a chance you might walk away.

I remember years ago, getting off a cruise in Ft Lauderdale where there was a bus to WDW for those who opted for an add on excursion.

With so many repeat cruisers, I can see Disney wanting to add more ports before people drift to other cruise lines for other destinations.

Carrie
01-07-2008, 09:19 PM
If they don't get a bigger terminal or move some of the ships elsewhere, that's going to be tight.